AUTHETICITY OF HADEETH WHICH SAYS THAT SAHABAS SAID “YAA MUHAMMAD””


كَتَبَ إِلَيَّ السَّرِيُّ : عَنْ شُعَيْبٍ ، عَنْ سَيْفٍ ، عن مبشر بْن الفضيل ، عن جبير بْن صخر ، عن عاصم بْن عمر بْن الخطاب ، قال : قحط الناس زمان عمر عاما ، فهزل المال ، فقال أهل بيت من مزينة من أهل البادية لصاحبهم : قد بلغنا ، فاذبح لنا شاة. قال : ليس فيهن شيء ، فلم يزالوا به حتى ذبح لهم شاة ، فسلخ عن عظم أحمر ، فنادى : يا محمداه ، فأري فيما يرى النائم أن رسول اللَّه صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ أتاه ، فقال : ” أبشر بالحيا ، ائت عمر ، فأقرئه مني السلام ، وقل له : إن عهدي بك وأنت وفي العهد شديد العقد ، فالكيس الكيس يا عمر ” ، فجاء حتى أتى باب عمر ، فقال لغلامه : استأذن لرسول رسول اللَّه صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ ، فأتى عمر فأخبره ففزع ، وقال : رأيت به مسا ؟ قال : لا ، قال : فأدخله ، فدخل فأخبره الخبر ، فخرج فنادى في الناس ، وصعد المنبر ، وقال : أنشدكم بالذي هداكم للإسلام ، هل رأيتم مني شيئا تكرهونه ؟ قالوا : اللهم لا ، قالوا : ولم ذاك ؟ فأخبرهم ففطنوا ولم يفطن ، فقالوا : إنما استبطأك في الاستسقاء ، فاستسق بنا ، فنادى في الناس ، فقام ، فخطب فأوجز ، ثم صلى ركعتين ، فأوجز ، ثم قال : اللهم عجزت عنا أنصارنا ، وعجز عنا حولنا وقوتنا ، وعجزت عنا أنفسنا ، ولا حول ولا قوة إلا بك ، اللهم فاسقنا ، وأحي العباد والبلاد.

Narrated Aasim bin umar al khattab that During the Caliphate of Umar Bin Khattab (May Allah Be Pleased With Him) in 18 Hijri when the Famine struck. This year is known as “Aam-u-Ramadah”. The tribe of Banu Mazeena said to one of their men (Bilal) that “we are dying of hunger, slaughter a sheep”. So He (Bilal) said: “There is nothing left in sheeps. But people insisted so he slaughtered a sheep. When the sheep was flayed (removing of skin) they found a red bone inside. On seeing this that person (Bilal) said “Ya Muhamada”. At night he saw the Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) in his dream saying to him: “ Greeting about your life. Go to Umar, pay my salaam to him and also tell him O Umar! You are the one who keeps his promises well, so remember my promise. Umar! Use your wisdom. This person of Banu Mazeena woke up and went straight to Umar (may Allah Be pleased with him) and said to the doorman: “Seek permission from Umar for the messenger of Rasoolulah (Peace be Upon Him).” Umar (May Allah Be Pleased With Him) became nervous when the doorman conveyed this message to him and said: “ Bring him to me”. This person was asked to come inside and he told the whole story. Umar (May Allah Be Pleased With Him) gathered the people, stood up on the pulpit and said: “ Swear upon the one who has blessed you with Islam, did you find any mistake in me? People said: “ No. But what happened? Umar (May Allah Be Pleased With Him) told people the story of the dream of Bilal. People understood but Umar (may Allah be pleased with him) did not. People told him that you have delayed in praying Salat-ul-Istesqa’. Pray Salat-ul-Istesqa’ with us. Umar (May Allah Be Pleased WIthHim) made an announcement, gathered the people, stood up and delivered a short Khutba, then prayed two short Rakats and then prayed for rain.

TAREEKH AT-TABARI (HADITH 989)
(AL-BIDAYA WAN’NIHAYA IBNE KATHEER 91/7)

CONTENT. :-

1) IT IS PERMISSIBLE TO SAY YAA MUHAMMAD?

2) “SHOAIB BIN IBRAHEEN KOOFI” IS MAJHOOL.

3) “SAIF BIN UMAR KOOFI” IS UNANIMOUSLY “DAEEF WA MATROOK” (WEAK AND REJECTED).

4) “MUBASHIR BIN FUZAIL” IS MAJHOOL (UNKNOWN).

5) “JUBAIR BIN SAKHAR” MAJHOOL (UNKNOWN).

6) HANAFIS SCHOLARS DIFFERED REGARDING PRAYING SALATUL ISTISKHA IN CONGREGATION.

7) DREAMS ARE NOT EVIDENCE IN ISLAM & REJECTED IF AGAINST SHARIAH.

8) CONCLUSION.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

1) IT IS PERMISSIBLE TO SAY YAA MUHAMMAD?

IN SHA ALLAH WE WILL EXPLAIN IN SEPARATE ARTICLE.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

2) “SHUAYB BIN IBRAHEEM AL-KOOFI” IS MAJHOOL. :-

http://asmaur-rijaal.blogspot.in/2013/12/shuayb-bin-ibraaheem-al-koofi.html

jazakallahu khair bro raza hassan for providing asma ur rijaal.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

3) “SAIF BIN UMAR KOOFI” IS UNANIMOUSLY “DAEEF WA MATROOK” (WEAK AND REJECTED). :-

http://asmaur-rijaal.blogspot.in/2013/12/sayf-bin-umar-at-tameemi-al-koofi.html

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

4) “MUBASHIR BIN FUZAIL” IS MAJHOOL (UNKNOWN). :-

IMAM UQAILI SAID :-

مجهول بالنقل ،إسناده لا يصح


“This person is “Majhool” in narrating Hadith, Chain of narration of this hadith is not authentic”.

(DHU’FAA-UL-KABEER: 236/4)

IMAM AD-DAHABI SAID :-

لا يدرى من هو ؟

Don’t know who is he”.

(MEEZAN-UL-ETEDAAL: 434/3)

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

5) “JUBAIR BIN SAKHAR” MAJHOOL (UNKNOWN).:-

The verification of the narrator “Jubair Bin Sakhar” is required.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

6) HANAFIS SCHOLARS DIFFERED REGARDING PRAYING SALATUL ISTISKHA IN CONGREGATION. :-


Secondly,mostly the barelvi Hanafis themselves quote this Hadith as an evidence in their support, though in this fabricated narration which they present, The Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) not only ordered Umar (May Allah Be Pleased With Him) to pray Salat-ul-Isteqa but also declared it as an act of wisdom, then Umar (May Allah Be Pleased With Him) acted accordingly to the order of the Prophet (Peace be Upon Him) and prayed Salat-ul-Istesqa in congregation. Whereas the Imam of the Muqallid Hanafis Abu Haneefa did not declare Salat-ul-Istesqa as a Sunnah. Thus in the revered book of Hanafi fiqh “Hidaya” Imam Abu Haneefa has been quoted as:

ليس في الاستسقاءصلاةمسنونة في جماعته…..ورسول الله استسقى ولم تر وعنه صلاة

“ Praying Salat-ul-Isteqa in congregation is not a Sunnah of The Prophet Peace be Upon Him….. Prophet Peace be Upon Him did pray for rain but there is no report from the Prophet Peace Be Upon him about praying Salaah on this occasion.”

(HIDAYA FEE SHARAH BIDAYA AL-MUBTADI, KITABU SALAT,BAAB UL ISTESQA 176/1)

The hadith about the Prophet Peace be upon him praying Salat ul Istesqa in congregation are famous and well known. Ahadith about Salatul Istesqa and its method of praying has been narrated in books of ahadith in abundance. Here are some references from khutube Sitta

[SAHEEH BUKHARI:1012, SAHEEH MUSLIM 894, SUNAN ABU DAOOD:1161, SUNAN TIRMIDHI: 556, SUNAN NISAI:1505, SUNAN IBNE MAJAH:1266)

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

7) DREAMS ARE NOT EVIDENCE IN ISLAM & REJECTED IF AGAINST SHARIAH. :-

http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/aqeedah/281-dreams-are-not-evidence-in-religion#axzz2qGdvdyKY

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

8) CONCLUSION. :-

Above narrations is mawdoo, & it not permissible to call Prophet Muhammed p.b.u.h by his name.

AHMAD RAZA KHAN BARELVI SAID :-

Even we do not consider it correct to call the Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) with his name.

(RUHOW KI DUNIYA AHMAD RAZA KHAN PAGE 245)

PREPARED BY SHAYKH GHULAM MUSTAFA ZAHEER , COMPILED & EDITED BY SYED MASHWANEE & AIJAZ SHAIKH.

Posted on January 13, 2014, in TAWASSUL AND ISTIGATHA REFUTATIONS. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: